The Evolution of Macallan's Secondary Market: A Decade of Auction Data

The secondary whisky market has seen remarkable growth over the past decade, with Macallan remaining one of the most traded and sought-after brands. Through analysis of over 400,000 auction records, we can trace clear patterns in both pricing and market liquidity.

Trading Volume and Market Growth

Our data reveals a consistent pattern of increasing market participation. For Macallan's core expressions, particularly the 10 and 12-year-old bottlings, trading volumes grew significantly between 2012 and 2018. The 10-year-old expression saw peak trading in 2018 with 276 bottles changing hands, up from just 7 sales in 2012. This dramatic increase in volume suggests growing confidence in the secondary market and wider acceptance of whisky as an alternative asset class.

Price Trajectories

The most striking price movements occurred between 2016 and 2023, with the Macallan 10-year-old serving as a bellwether for the broader market. Starting from a modest £77 average price in 2016, the expression experienced a meteoric rise to £377 by 2023, representing nearly 400% growth. This appreciation wasn't linear, however, with significant volatility along the way. The most dramatic growth occurred in 2017, with a 73% year-over-year increase, followed by another 62% jump in 2018.

The 12-year-old expression demonstrated more stable growth patterns, though it still saw significant appreciation, particularly in 2018 with a 64% year-over-year increase. This stability in the 12-year market might reflect its position as a more mature and established expression in Macallan's portfolio.

Market Maturity and Liquidity

The data reveals three distinct phases in market development. The early years from 2012 to 2015 were characterized by relatively low trading volumes but stable prices, suggesting a market dominated by enthusiasts and collectors.

The middle period from 2016 to 2018 represents peak liquidity, with the highest number of transactions and dramatic price appreciation, indicating broader market participation and possibly speculative interest. Recent years have shown higher prices but lower trading volumes, possibly indicating a more selective market with greater emphasis on quality and provenance.

Market Dynamics and Future Outlook

Recent data suggests a potential market correction, with the Macallan 10-year-old experiencing a sharp 46% decline in 2024. This correction, combined with reduced trading volumes, might indicate a market that's becoming more discriminating. The initial surge in prices and volumes between 2016-2018 likely represented a period of market discovery, with participants trying to establish fair values for these bottles.

Looking ahead, the market appears to be entering a more mature phase. The reduced trading volumes but sustained higher prices compared to pre-2016 levels suggest that Macallan bottles are increasingly viewed as long-term holds rather than trading vehicles. This evolution mirrors the development of other alternative asset markets, where initial periods of high volatility and trading activity eventually give way to more stable, investment-focused behavior.

If you enjoyed this article, support us!